Broke down and ordered a set of TreadWright Wardens in 265 R 17 16, E-rated.
Finally had one of my BFG ATs go flat and no one would fix it due to tire wear and proximity of the nail to outside edge of the tire. We were offroading going from Green Valley Lake, CA (7,200') to Lucerne Valley, CA (2,953'), a distance of about 25 miles. We then took Cushenberry Grade back up to Big Bear Lake. Very steep grade that climbs up from 3,000' to 7,000' in about 6 miles. Many hairpin turns and on one there was a car broke down on the inside lane right at the apex. Car ahead of me and we both had to stop hard and go around it. About half a mile later, right rear tire was going flat. I pulled off and changed it, finding an additional nail in the middle of the tread. I'm sure the hard stop caused one to just let go. It's a bummer as there was at least 5,000 miles of tread left.
So, the plan is to mount 2 of the Treadwrights and install them on the front and move the two BFGs from the left side to the rear. Those two never had nails in them and as a result were always inflated properly and have probably 10K miles of tread left. I'll run those down and install the remaining two Treadwrights. I'm just determined to get every last mile out of the damn BFGs.
I'm hoping the Treadwrights give me 30K miles like the BFGs did, then I win that bet. Call me a guinea pig.