Are you guys recommending the Duralasts shopping at a different Autozone than me or what? I used to buy them all the time when I was young and poor, and never had a bit of luck with them. Only bought them because they were cheap, and only used them again because they were replaced under warranty. Same with Wal-Mart batteries, I believe they were both recycled batteries. When I was towing I went on countless no-start calls where they had a Neverstart under the hood.
I never did have a top of the line Duralast or Walmart Maxx battery though, I had and witnessed all those problems with the cheapie small car batteries. Do you suppose their top-line battery is something far better, perhaps just a rebadged Interstate or Exide? I do know one guy who swears by the WM Maxx.
I also went through a stage where I replaced a bunch of starters and alternators with Duralast remans, had to keep getting them warranteed. Finally stopped buying anything electrical unless it says ACDelco on it. I had ACDelco batteries for a few years, but they weren't matched and one eventually died and brought the other with it, so I bought two Diehard Silvers, didn't have enough money for Golds that day. I had switched to Golds in my old plowtrucks and was really impressed with them. These Silver series haven't been as impressive, I have killed them a few times now. I don't think it was necessarily the batteries fault, I think it was due to constantly loosening battery connections. Also run it out of fuel a couple times, and cranking it up again will usually kill them. If they die again I think I'll just replace them, even though it's only been about 3 years. Don't know what I'll get next, probably Diehard Golds.
We run Optimas in all our "company cars" which have a tremendous amount of onboard electronics and lighting, no problems with them but I have heard that they don't come back as well after being killed. A tech told me they will not keep coming back as many times from dead as a regular battery will. As many times as I've killed these Diehards I have now, I'm sure I've shortened the life of them quite a bit. I'll probably need to do something this season, plowing takes a whole lot out of them and I can't have any down time because of a stupid dead battery.