Mermber
@ak diesel driver (your thread link please?) here did a great write up on a differnent fanclutch and fan option using an electro viscous fanclutch so you can set your own desired engaugement temps to deal with your environment and uses better.
You can even wire in a simple on/ off switch that could e employed to enguage early on specific hills you want early fan cooling, or then off if crossing deep water as to not destroy the fan under water. I am not dure if he ever did, but you could also add a trinary switch in the a/c system and engage the fan for better condensor cooling as needed for a/c system.
Outside of his idea,
There has been a gluttony of others tried. I worked at a company that did in field testing for gm on the 6.5 back in the 90’s. The overheating was part of what we did. Our company didn’t solve it, but I think we helped them discover major parts of it. Working with a couple of their engineers, we discussed over a dozen variations of using the rear head cooling ports which GM kept blocked off. GM experiments with every conceivable application you can image using them. Don’t bother with the hose kits connecting them together and back to the heater hose circuit. Gm found devistating effects - basically moving the problem to another area. The only successful use of them involved 2 seperate waterpumps that were electronically controlled and exterior radiator packs via elaborate fittings with flow tubes in place of the block offs.
When they described it, we built one in house to see effects, and back in the 90’s material costs alone was over $1000. It’s results were not a complete fix, so...yeah.
Another option is the hmmwv fanclutch. It is an instant, 100% lockup clutch. It defaults to on. It is released by pressure from the power steering circuit via electric solenoid. Member here
@Twisted Steel Performance (@ link not working? Auto name fill wont happen) had one installed on his truck using the 4 bolt style Water pump with good success.
If I was to ever use the 4 bolt waterpump- one of any kind- I would absolutely use the hmmwv set up.
Viscous and electro viscous all have roughly a 5 year lifespan. The hmmwv is a rebuildable unit. Used ones can be had on ebay, as well as rebuild kits.
I have one that I am trying to build an adapter to make function on the spinon waterpump for the best of both worlds, but haven’t been able to spend any time on it in nearly 8 months now. A good friend in charge of a large hmmwv fleet had delays in getting the hmmwv fanclutches, and tried using viscous fan clutch system on several hmmwvs with devistating results. The advantage of the immediate 100% clutch was instantly proved.