Yes, the neighbor was confused as to the old style pumps between regular flow and high output.
The real spec numbers from GM are
97 GPM for the original 4 bolt pumps on v belt, and first serpentine belt pumps.
Then GM released the HO 4 bolt pump with spec of 127GPM.
Then the redesign of the pump which used the spinon was listed at 127 by GM also.
However in the AM General vs GM lawsuit which resulted in the creation of GEP, they (AM General) actually showed the spinon produced 130 gpm. Gm engineer stated in court it was still considered 127, and that the extra flow was byproduct of the easier flow through and less restriction. And that the balance flow is what eliminates the problem. So when GEP started producing the Optimizer, they were still not allowed to use the spinon balance flow design of GM until they released the sale of optimizers to the public and GM was released of their contract to HAVE TO build the 6.5. This was a sticking point because they showed that at 140 gpm it was too great and caused cavitation points on cylinder jackets and that was why their first balanced flow redesign they tried to get AM General to accept was declined. They already done their testing by that time after thousands of wasted hmmwv engines. So GM had to pay back a loss of 1/2 million bucks for that 140 gpm pump to AM General amongst some of their losses in the suits.
So when you see someone refering to a 127 or 130 gpm, understand the number is basically the same and not yet another redesign of GM’s pump. 95gpm is a number I have never heard of, possibly typo of 97?
Once all the time limits expired on GM 4 bolt waterpump warranties, Then GEP started it’s use of the spinon for hmmwvs.
So anyways, the balanced flow waterpump- which is the spinon waterpump style- has been going since then.
I would NEVER buy a reman waterpump after the fiasco of HO 4 bolts being rebuilt with 97 impellers. That just shows me some clown company could rebuild a spinon waterpump with an incorrect impeller. Remember, the impeller in the 127 HO pump is not the same as the 127 spinon balanced flow.
The reason the spinon waterpump corrects the issue is a redesign of the chambers in the body, and a complete redesign of the impeller.
So if Bill had a special impeller, different from GM’s last design, (which is in use now on all optimizers, 6500 and 6500-p400 option,that come as longblocks unless ordered for v belt use...
I wonder what he did to improve on it. Because the “balance flow” is within 1% of balanced. And at an actual 130 gpm and problems at 140, less than a 7% increase in flow? And if so did they do the turbulence testing?
He is always working on improvements and should be commended for it. But much like the rear head cooling kits he (amongst many others) used to sell- they proved to not just be not helping but damaging. As I mentioned many times before, I appreciate him quitting selling them (too many other places still after a quick buck still do). My concern would be that another attempt to make more improvement could cause issues.
If not and he found info showing lets say 137 gpm is the peak performance without issues, I would sure like to know it is available, for myself and others out there. Especially since other Hummers are being done with multiple radiators, and I may end up with that result still.
Or is it kinda like the camshaft thing where it sounds like it has great potential to smooth out power feeding a sidemount turbo, yet would be obvious counter productive on a centermount like hummers/vans. But he won’t share enough details to allow customers to make an informed decision before purchase. Buy it and see just doesn’t work out with these engines sometimes.
I get it he risks someone copying the idea if the extra flow from 130- but much like Kennedy’s fan clutch- anyone that learns much about the cooling system knows faster and higher percentage of lockup works better, and since Hayden and the other supplier before then(forgot name) makes and sells them only to him for a just under 10% increase in fan speed-not sure that many will bother with milling or casting an impeller to compete with limited sales. Someone would have to spend thousands to knock off his design, unless they (or he) just shot from the hip- which is just stupid knowing all the history of problems in these systems.