And that there is the difference - good post, Rhino.
Chicago, I would kill to have a Penninsular 18:1 setup with a holset like you're running (by the way, is it an HY35 (like you said) or an HX35 (ilike in your sig)? - there is a difference, for those wanting to build their own.)
However, I think Turbine Doc's point was, as rhino mentioned, about a stock engine (21:1) - just swapping the turbo, nothing else. We know the ATT is suited really well for that application and that the efficiency profile matches the engine needs. Anything bigger, we probably need an intercooler and some way to restrict boost levels, in my opinion.
Of course, I've been wrong before
I have been swapping back and forth with the HX and HY. Just depending on my mood :smile5:
Lately, I have been driving long distances a lot the HY shows better milage on the highway.
I guess the point that I have been trying to make is that if you want a 6.5 that makes great power, gets great fuel economy and will have solid reliability, spend the money (if you have it) and go to 18:1 with more boost. That way, the turbo is doing the work to make power and not the crank-rod-piston, trying to compress more gas.
I cruise at 75 with 10-12 psi and the turbo is making the power to keep the truck moving at that speed. And in doing so, the truck makes no black smoke under load and the fuel economy is phenomenal (for an IDI engine).
I would just like to know who is getting a LEGITIMATE 22 MPG? And hell, if my set-up was in a 1/2 ton or non-lifted 3/4 ton, it would be even better.
I am not saying anything is wrong with the ATT or 21:1 but if anybody every has the opportunity, which about 1 out of 4 here do when they end up blowing their engine, to just make the switch to 18:1.
I mean hell, I wonder what the ATT would do on an 18:1 engine? The compressor might be a little small but if you had an S engine and mech. pump, it might work great.
I have been around for a while and not to toot my own horn but I have pioneered some great stuff as far as ATA inter-coolers, larger turbos and big exhaust setups. And in doing all of this, I have put over 50K miles on my rig with the 18:1 motor and high boost with zero issues.
With that said, I just want people who have the option to consider the fact that if you want to spend a shinny nickle on an engine, go with a lower compression and let the turbo do the work and not the engine.
Look at the drag racing world. The fastest cars out there on the strip have forced air. No more high compression nitrous motors. ANything that is going 8's in the 1/4 mile has a turbo, big blower or two turbos. And they last all season unlike 15:1 gas motors that have to get rebuilt every other weekend.
My $.02