From everything I've read the pointer (beam style) is just as accurate. With the added advantage that it doesn't need to be recalibrated. The only advantage the clicker style has is it eliminates human error and is easier to use. But needs to be recalibrated periodically. Last time I had mine recalibrated it was off about 5lbs at 100 ft pds. Not alot but it cost me almost as much as the original purchase. The cheapie import can be way off.